Skip to main content

Silence is not an Option

The Washington Post has collected data on all people who have been killed by police officers since January 1, 2015. According to that data, in 134 of those police killings between January 1, 2015 and September 20, 2016 the victim was unarmed. The following commentary is based on the data related to those 134 unarmed victims.

According to Census Bureau’s March 2016 Current Population Survey, 61% of the United States population is white, 12% is black, and 18% is hispanic. Therefore, would mathematically estimate that approximately 61% of those victims were white, 12% of those victims were black, and 18% of those victims were hispanic. This would result in 81 white victims, 16 black victims, and 24 hispanic victims. However, according to the data collected by The Washington Post, there have been 51 white victims, 53 black victims, and 23 hispanic victims. Here is a chart displaying the data:

Race
Census Bureau’s March 2016 Current Population Survey
Mathematical estimate of number of police killings of unarmed victims by race out of 134 based on population percentages
Actual number of police killings of unarmed victims by race out of 134 based on data collected by The Washington Post
Black
12% of the USA population
16
53 (40% of all victims)
White
61% of the USA population
81
51 (38% of all victims)
Hispanic
18% of the USA population
24
23 (17% of all victims)

That is, while white people make up 61% of the USA population, they make up only 38% of the unarmed victims, and while black people make up only 12% of the USA population, they make up 40% of the unarmed victims.

The disproportional police killings of unarmed black and white individuals is a very serious problem. Police brutality is a terrible problem, but it is not even the real issue here. Police brutality towards black individuals is a fatal symptom of an even more deadly disease, which is the systemic racism that gives privilege to people with white skin while demeaning everyone else. There has been conflict and bloodshed over racial lines in our country since its birth, and all non-white groups in the USA have been marginalized and disregarded ever since white people set foot in the USA. Systemic racism has to do with white people who claim that they are not racist not realizing that they are privileged, it has to do with white silence in the face of non-white pain.

To my white brothers and sisters: All of our thoughts and opinions are shaped by our experiences, and as white people, our experiences do not match the experiences of non-white people in our country that we have thoughts and opinions about.  We cannot understand what it is like for non-white people in our country, but we can see that they are hurting. The media can twist things, but the data indicates that unarmed black people are being killed at a faster rate than any other group in our nation. Silence never really was an option for us, but we have a history of being silent anyway. Let’s ask questions and be willing to listen, let’s loosen our grip on our views so that we can begin to sympathize with what our neighbors are going through, let’s recognize that there are ugly things happening in our country and we have not done much about it, let’s stop hiding, stop ignoring, stop blaming, and start accepting responsibility. Let’s stop being silent.

To my black brothers and sisters: Though I cannot truly understand your pain, I see you hurting and I hurt with you. I care, though I don’t always know how to express that. Thank you for your patience and grace with me thus far and in the future, because I know I will continue to need it.

Comments

  1. Hannah, I am proud of you for this. You are a great help at Bethel Gary as we walk together the path of reconciliation. This path contains difficult truths for us all. Thank you for your insight and you heart for others through Christ. #reconciliationnow #livereconciled
    Pastor Ray

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Let's talk more about friendship

Friendship is one of my favorite things in the world, but I rarely find posts or articles or podcasts or sermons or books or songs about it. Advice and discourse about marriage and parenting and family relationships are abundant, but sometimes friendship seems to be missing from conversations. Songs about romantic love can be easily found on any radio station in any genre at any time of day, but songs that celebrate friendship are harder to find. A quick Amazon search for books about marriage immediately lists multiple best sellers, devotionals, and popular authors. Searching Amazon for books about friendship, on the other hand, results in a smattering of books, unfamiliar names, and a few guides for making friendship bracelets. There is a notable lack of best sellers and devotionals. Why is this?  Perhaps, in the rush to find a romantic partner, we overlook and undervalue friendship.  Perhaps we don't do a good job of making time in adult life to cultivate and prioritize frie...

Teacher Diaries: I was wrong about my students

Lazy. Dumb. Trouble. Attitude. She must have been forced to take Spanish. She doesn't want to be here and won't do any work until the last week of the semester when she comes whining for extra credit. I've seen him in the dean's office. I think he lives there. See that look on her face? That's a look that says that she is here to make my life miserable for 55 minutes a day. Thoughts like these ran through my mind when I first met my students back in August. None of these assumptions were positive, all of them were based on external appearance and behavior observed during a 55 minute class period, and none of them were actually true. Ever since that day, my students have been chipping away at these theories, sometimes bit by bit as with a chisel, and sometimes with the mighty power of a backhoe tractor. The guys that I thought would cause trouble? They are kind, ready to help, willing to participate, and eager to learn Spanish. The girls that I as...

Blood on our hands

Ahmaud Arbery died, and there is blood on our hands. It is his blood and Botham Jean's blood and Atatiana Jefferson's blood and Tamir Rice's blood and Philando Castile's blood and Trayvon Martin's blood and Eric Garner's blood and the blood of dozens of other black men and women who have become hashtags and the uncounted others whose stories died with them. I know, you are not the one who pulled the trigger. Neither did I. I believe murder is wrong. I'm sure you would agree. How is it, then, that I can say that this man's blood is on our hands? And whose hands am I even referring to? The hands in question are my own. I am writing about my hands. As a citizen of the United States of America, as a Christian, as a human of European ancestry with white skin, there is blood on my hands. It might be on yours, too. Ahmaud Arbery's blood is on our hands because white supremacy is present in our hearts and our homes and our churches. We would never say ...